Changes

== The Policies Background ==On 5-Nov-2008, [[OCLC]] announced the Policy for Use and Transfer of [[WorldCat]]® Records to replace the Guidelines for the Use and Transfer of OCLC-Derived Records. The goals of the policy, as described by OCLC, were "to modernize record use and transfer practices for application on the Web, foster new uses of WorldCat data that benefit members and clarify data sharing rights and restrictions." This new policy generated considerable discussion in the library community, including two petitions, several trade publication articles, and over 80 blog posts with related comments.

* On 13-Jan-2009, OCLC announced a [http://www.oclc.org/worldcat/catalog/policy/ board/default.htm Review Board of Shared Data Creation and Stewardship] with a charge to: consult with librarians and member representatives as appropriate; review reports, letters and comments including blog and listserv messages from the global library community regarding the revised Policy; and recommend principles of shared data creation and changes in the Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat® WorldCat Records] (second that will preserve the community around WorldCat infrastructure and final version)* services, and strengthen libraries. The Review Board submitted its [http://marcwww.coffeecodeoclc.netorg/oclc_2008_11_02worldcat/ Archived copy of first versioncatalog/FinalReport_ReviewBoard.pdf final report]* to OCLC on 22-Jun-2009 recommending that the proposed policy be withdrawn and a Record Use Policy Development Task Force be formed along with a "formal, transparent and well-managed process" to create a new policy. In a [http://www.librarythingoclc.comorg/wikinews/indexreleases/200939.php?title=OCLC_Policy_Changes&diff=11748&oldid=11747 Diff between the two versionshtm news release] posted on 26-Jun-2009, OCLC accepted these recommendations.

* [http://wwwOn 7-April-2010, the Review Board of Shared Data Curation and Stewardship posted their draft policy for a period of review and comment (see link below).oclc.org/support/documentation/worldcat/records/guidelines/default.htm Previous 1987 version]

This page documents the discussion of members of the library community surrounding the revision of the Guidelines and creation of the Policy. It can be edited by anyone who has registered for an account on the Code4Lib wiki. [[Special:Userlogin|Registration]] on the Code4Lib wiki is open to anyone with an e-mail address. == Petition The Policy == Links to various forms of the policy -- previous editions, drafts, etc -- in reverse chronological order. * [http://www.oclc.org/worldcat/catalog/policy/default.htm WorldCat Rights and Responsibilities for the OCLC Cooperative] (7-Apr-2010) * [http://www.oclc.org/us/en/news/releases/20092.htm Press release regarding the Review Board of Shared Data Creation and Stewardship]* [http://lists.ala.org/wws/arc/lita-l/2009-03/msg00117.html Announcement of OCLC Review Board Survey] (via LITA-L mailing list)  * [http://www.oclc.org/worldcat/catalog/policy/policy.htm Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat® Records] (Last known update is 19-Nov-2008; this version is in PDF)* [http://www.oclc.org/worldcat/catalog/policy/ OCLC's summary statement about the policy]* [http://www.oclc.org/support/documentation/worldcat/records/guidelines/default.htm Guidelines for the Use and Transfer of OCLC-Derived Records] (the "Previous 1987 version")  * [http://marc.coffeecode.net/oclc_2008_11_02/ Archived copy of 2-Nov-2008 version]* [http://www.librarything.com/wiki/index.php?title=OCLC_Policy_Changes&diff=11748&oldid=11747 Difference between the November 2nd version and the November 5th version]* [http://www.librarything.com/wiki/index.php?title=OCLC_Policy_Changes&diff=12067&oldid=12062 Difference between the November 5th version and the November 19th version] == Petitions == On November 13, 2008, a petition called [http://watchdog.net/c/stop-oclc Stop the OCLC powergrab!] was started by Aaron Swartz to repeal the new policy. Background in his blog post, [http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/oclcscam Stealing Your Library: The OCLC Powergrab]. On December 1, 2008, Elaine Sanchez created a new [http://www.petitiononline.com/oclc/petition.html petition] with more depth and specificity. The petition calls for OCLC to vacate the new policy, create a more open process for revising the 1987 guidelines, and assert that the records are the property of the respective contributing members. Ms. Sanchez [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cA5EA7312DD1822479490004ED396177E96E8D2D455%40BOBCATMAIL4.matrix.txstate.edu%3e posted an announcement about it] on the Autocat mailing list.

* ''Inside Higher {| class="wikitable sortable"|- style="text-align: left;"! Date !! Author !! Title|-| 2008-11-02 || Reese, Terry || [http://oregonstate.edu/~reeset/blog/archives/574 OCLC’s proposed new guidelines for the transfer of bibliographic records]|-| 2008-11-03 || Reese, Terry || [http://oregonstate.edu/~reeset/blog/archives/579 What would it look like if OCLC was broken up?]|-| 2008-11-03 || Corrado, Ed|| [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2008/11/03/oclcs-new-policy-for-use-and-transfer-of-worldcat-records/ oclc’s new policy for use and transfer of worldcat records]|-| 2008-11-04 || Calhoun, Karen || [http://community.oclc.org/metalogue/archives/2008/11/notes-on-oclcs-updated-record.html Notes on OCLC'' s Updated Record Use Policy] (NC)|- | 2008-11-04 || Panlibus || [http://wwwblogs.insidehigheredtalis.com/newspanlibus/archives/2008/11/14what-are-oclc-playing-at.php What are OCLC playing at?]|-| 2008-11-04 || Mahoney, Richard || [http:/worldcat Maelstrom Over Metadata/lists.indexdata.dk/pipermail/yazlist/2008-November/002594.html Yazlist: Impact of new OCLC `Policy for Use and Transfer of WC Records' on federated search/virtual union catalogues] (NC)* |-| 2008-11-05 || Coombs, Karen || [http://www.librarywebchic.net/wordpress/2008/11/05/whos-record-is-it-anyway/ Who’s record is it anyway?]|-| 2008-11-05 || Corrado, Ed || [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2008/11/05/karen-calhoun-on-worldcat/ karen calhoun on oclc’s updated record use policy]|-| 2008-11-05 || Corrado, Ed || [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2008/11/05/new-oclc-policy-on-worldcat-records-re-released/ new oclc policy on worldcat records re-released]|-| 2008-11-05 || Open Content Alliance || [http://www.opencontentalliance.org/?p=162 New OCLC Records Policy Generates Debate]|-| 2008-11-05 || Reese, Terry || [http://oregonstate.edu/~reeset/blog/archives/582 A look at the Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat Records revision]|-| 2008-11-05 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2008/11/05/more-on-oclcs-policies/ More on OCLC’s policies]|-| 2008-11-06 || ''Library Journal'' - || [http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA6612175.html After Delay, OCLC Lays Out New Policy for Records Use and Transfer] (NC)* Aaron Swartz |- | 2008-11-06 || Repohate || [http://wwwrepohate.aaronswblogspot.com/weblog2008/11/declaration-of-independance-of-metadata.html Declaration of Independance of Metadata]|-| 2008-11-06 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2008/11/06/copyright-trivia/ copyright trivia], [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2008/11/06/one-more/ one more]|-| 2008-11-06 || Styles, Rob || [http://dynamicorange.com/2008/11/06/oclc-record-usage-copyright-contracts-and-the-law/oclcreply OCLC on , Record Usage, Copyright, Contracts and the RunLaw] |-| 2008-11-07 || Corrado, Ed || [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2008/11/07/update-on-oclc-worldcat-policy/ update on oclc worldcat policy]|-| 2008-11-07 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2008/11/07/a-logical-oclc-argument/ A logical OCLC argument]|-| 2008-11-07 || Wallis, Richard (NCPanlibus)|| [http://blogs.talis.com/panlibus/archives/2008/11/keeping-the-worldcat-in-the-bag.php Keeping the WorldCat in the bag]* Aaron Swartz |- | 2008-11-12 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://wwwbibwild.aaronswwordpress.com/weblog2008/oclcscam Stealing Your Library: The 11/12/i-dont-actually-want-to-destroy-oclc/ I don’t actually want to destroy OCLC Powergrab] |-| 2008-11-12 || Uncontrolled Vocabulary #62 (NCpodcast)|| [http://uncontrolledvocabulary.com/2008/11/12/uncontrolled-vocabulary-62-a-reliable-guide-to-unicorns/ A Reliable Guide to Unicorns]* Annoyed Librarian |- | 2008-11-12 || Wallis, Richard (Panlibus) || [http://wwwblogs.libraryjournaltalis.com/blogpanlibus/580000658archives/post2008/29003662911/oclc-any-questions.html How I Learned to Stop Worrying php OCLC – any questions?]|-| 2008-11-13 || Hartman-Caverly, Sarah || [http://seriallyyours.wordpress.com/2008/11/13/final-policy-for-use-and Love -transfer-of-worldcat-records-post-by-oclc/ Final ‘Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat Records’ Posted by OCLC]* Ben |-| 2008-11-13 || O'Steen - , Ben || [http://oxfordrepo.blogspot.com/2008/11/oclc-viral-licence-being-added-to.html OCLC - viral licence being added to WorldCat data]* Devanshu Mehta |- | 2008-11-13 || Slashdot || [http://wwwnews.geekactivismslashdot.comorg/2008article.pl?sid=08/11/1813/on1929213 Non-communityProfit Org Claims Rights In Library Catalog Data] (NC)|-based| 2008-collaboration11-lesson-from-the-oclc-debacle13 || Swartz, Aaron || [http:/ On Community-Based Collaboration/www.aaronsw.com/weblog/oclcscam Stealing Your Library: Lesson From the The OCLC DebaclePowergrab](NC)* Ed Corrado |- | 2008-11-14 || ''Inside Higher Ed'' || [http://blogwww.ecorradoinsidehighered.uscom/news/2008/11/0514/karen-calhoun-on-worldcat/ karen calhoun on oclc’s updated record use policyMaelstrom Over Metadata](NC)* Ed Corrado |- | 2008-11-14 || Calhoun, Karen / Roy Tennant / Richard Wallis || [http://blogblogs.ecorradotalis.uscom/panlibus/archives/2008/11/05/new-oclc-policytalk-onwith-worldcattalis-recordsabout-rethe-released/ new oclc policy on worldcat records re-releasedrecord-use-policy.php OCLC Talk with Talis about the new Record Use Policy]* Ed Corrado |- | 2008-11-14 || Calhoun, Karen (via Autocat) || [http://blognews.ecorradogmane.usorg/2008/11/07/update-onfind-root.php?message_id=%3c2FA61018D659CF4B95A0F938AE66965A037EAA5A%40OAEXCH4SERVER.oa.oclc-worldcat-policy/ update on oclc worldcat policy.org%3e OCLC Record Use Policy](NC)* Ed Corrado |- | 2008-11-14 || Corrado, Ed || [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2008/11/14/oclc-worldcat-record-policy-makes-it-to-inside-higher-ed-and-slashdot/ OCLC WorldCat Record Policy makes it to Inside Higher Ed and Slashdot]* Ed Corrado |- | 2008-11-14 || Libology || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2008/11/14/more-oclc-comments.html More OCLC Comments]|-| 2008-11-14 || Litwin, Roy || [http://libraryjuicepress.com/blog/?p=792 OCLC Powergrab?]|-| 2008-11-14 || Sanchez, Elaine (via Autocat) || [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cA5EA7312DD1822479490004ED396177E96E853AE0A%40BOBCATMAIL4.matrix.txstate.edu%3e Petition to stop OCLC from initiating the new WorldCat Policy] (NC)|-| 2008-11-14 || Styles, Rob || [http://dynamicorange.com/2008/11/14/more-oclc-policy/ More OCLC Policy…]|-| 2008-11-14 || Suburban Banshee || [http://suburbanbanshee.wordpress.com/2008/11/14/oclc-gets-grabby/ OCLC Gets Grabby]|-| 2008-11-15 || Corrado, Ed || [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2008/11/15/talis-podcast-about-oclc-worldcat-record-use-policy-with-karen-clahoun-and-roy-tennant/ Talis Podcast about OCLC WorldCat Record Use Policy with Karen Clahoun and Roy Tennant]* Elaine Sanches (via Autocat) |- | 2008-11-15 || LISnews || [http://news.gmanelisnews.org/findoclc_claims_ownership_data_opacs OCLC Claims Ownership of Data In OPACs]|-root| 2008-11-15 || Swartz, Aaron || [http://www.php?message_id=%3cA5EA7312DD1822479490004ED396177E96E853AE0A%40BOBCATMAIL4aaronsw.matrix.txstate.edu%3e Petition to stop com/weblog/oclcreply OCLC from initiating on the new WorldCat PolicyRun] (NC)|-| 2008-11-15 || West, Jessamyn || [http://www.librarian.net/stax/2536/what-is-up-with-oclc/ What is up with OCLC?]|-| 2008-11-16 || Mazzocchi, Stefano || [http://www.betaversion.org/~stefano/linotype/news/220/ Rule #1 for Surviving Paradigm Shifts: Don’t S* Jonathan Rochkind *t Where You Eat]|- | 2008-11-16 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2008/11/16/more-oclc/ more OCLC]* jrochkind |- | 2008-11-16 || Schwartz, Christine || [http://bibwildwww.wordpresscatalogingfutures.com/catalogingfutures/2008/11/05/moreessential-listening-calhoun-and-tennant-on-oclcs-policiespolicy.html Essential listening: Calhoun and Tennant on OCLC's policy]|-| 2008-11-17 || Alford, Larry (Chair, OCLC Board of Trustees) || [http:/ More /www.oclc.org/worldcat/catalog/policy/trusteesletter.pdf An open letter to the OCLC membership on OCLC’s policiesthe WorldCat Record Use Policy](NC)* jrochkind |- | 2008-11-17 || Annoyed Librarian || [http://bibwildwww.wordpresslibraryjournal.com/blog/580000658/post/290036629.html How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love OCLC] (NC)|-| 2008-11-18 || Mehta, Devanshu || [http://www.geekactivism.com/2008/11/0618/copyrighton-triviacommunity-based-collaboration-lesson-from-the-oclc-debacle/ copyright triviaOn Community-Based Collaboration: Lesson From the OCLC Debacle]|-| 2008-11-18 || Styles, Rob || [http://bibwilddynamicorange.com/2008/11/18/schroedingers_worldcat/ Schroedinger’s WorldCat]|-| 2008-11-18 || Baker, Gavin || [http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/2008/11/oclc-fighting-oa-to-bibliographic-data.html OCLC fighting OA to bibliographic data]|-| 2008-11-18 || Lawson, Steve || [http://stevelawson.name/seealso/archives/2008/11/clarifications_and_cautions.html Clarifications and Cautions]|-| 2008-11-19 || Lang, John || [http://lonewolflibrarian.wordpress.com/2008/11/0619/oneoclc-moreand-google-policy-discussion-continues111908/ one moreOCLC and Google Policy Discussion Continues…11.19.08]* jrochkind |- | 2008-11-19 || Library 2.0 Gang (podcast) || [http://bibwildlibrarygang.wordpresstalis.com/2008/11/0719/alibrary-logical20-gang-1008-policy-oclc-argumentgoogle-book-search/ A logical Library 2.0 Gang 10/08: Policy – OCLC argument& Google Book Search]* jrochkind |- | 2008-11-19 || Sauers, Michael (screenshot) || [http://bibwildwww.wordpressflickr.com/photos/travelinlibrarian/3044179351/ Hey Roy, remember this?] (NC)|-| 2008-11-19 || Uncontrolled Vocabulary #63 (podcast) || [http://uncontrolledvocabulary.com/2008/11/1219/iuncontrolled-dontvocabulary-actually63-wantaacr3-tonow-destroywith-frbr/ Uncontrolled Vocabulary #63 - AACR3, now with FRBR] (OCLC discussion starts at the 20:50 mark.)|-| 2008-11-19 || Mark Ockerbloom, John || [http://everybodyslibraries.com/2008/11/19/drawing-a-line-in-the-sand-part-1-the-importance-of-open-library-metadata/ Drawing a line in the sand, Part 1: The importance of open library metadata]|-| 2008-11-20 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2008/11/oclc-policy-re-re-released-now-in.php OCLC Policy Re-re-released, now in unfriendly PDF]|-| 2008-11-20 || Jastram, Iris || [http:/ /pegasuslibrarian.blogspot.com/2008/11/oclc-kerfuffle-in-which-i-write-much.html The OCLC Kerfuffle: In which I don’t actually want write much but come to destroy few conclusions]|-| 2008-11-20 || Bridle, James || [http://www.liberalconspiracy.org/2008/11/20/the-great-public-library-scandal/ The great public library scandal]|-| 2008-11-21 || Sauers, Michael || [http://www.travelinlibrarian.info/2008/11/oclc-and-cc.html OCLCand CC]* Karen Calhoun & Roy Tennant with Richard Wallis (podcast) |- | 2008-11-21 || Mehta, Devanshu || [http://www.geekactivism.com/2008/11/21/the-continuing-adventures-of-worldcat-conditions-not-restrictions/ Continuing Adventures of WorldCat: Conditions, not Restrictions]|-| 2008-11-21 || Wallis, Richard || [http://blogs.talis.com/panlibus/archives/2008/11/oclc-talkquestions-answers-and-an-open-letter.php OCLC - Questions Answers and an Open Letter]|-| 2008-11-21 || Coyle, Karen || [http://kcoyle.blogspot.com/2008/11/fork-worldcat.html Fork WorldCat]|-| 2008-11-21 || Mark Ockerbloom, John || [http://everybodyslibraries.com/2008/11/21/drawing-a-line-in-the-sand-part-2-problems-with-talisoclcs-aboutcatalog-policy/ Drawing a line in thesand, Part 2: Problems with OCLC’s catalog policy]|-new| 2008-record11-24 || Kleinman, Molly || [http://mollykleinman.com/2008/11/24/oclc-licensing-saga/ The OCLC data licensing saga: Adapt or die]|-| 2008-11-24 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2008/11/24/of-identifiers-matching-oclcnums-and-umlaut/ Of Identifiers, matching, OCLCnums, and Umlaut]|-| 2008-11-24 || Mark Ockerbloom, John || [http://everybodyslibraries.com/2008/11/24/drawing-a-line-in-the-sand-part-3-how-to-respond/ Drawing a line in the sand, Part 3: How to respond?]|-| 2008-11-24 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2008/11/24/creative-commons-is-not-appropriate-for-data/ Creative Commons is not appropriate for data]|-| 2008-11-25 || Salo, Dorothea || [http://cavlec.yarinareth.net/2008/11/25/oclc-catalogue-records-and-labor/ OCLC, catalogue records, and labor]|-| 2008-11-25 || Mehta, Devanshu || [http://www.geekactivism.com/2008/11/25/i-can-haz-worldcats/ I Can Haz Worldcat?]|-| 2008-11-26 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2008/11/26/380/ OCLC, and what we lose without openness (a True Story)]|-| 2008-11-26 || Corrado, Ed || [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2008/11/26/putting-your-golden-eggs-in-one-basket/ Putting Your Golden Eggs in One Basket]|-| 2008-11-27 || NELLCO USS project blog || [http://blog.nellco.org/?p=47 USS Use of OCLC MARC Records]|-| 2008-11-28 || Coyle, Karen || [http://kcoyle.blogspot.com/2008/11/oclc-use-policy-details-your-records.php html OCLC Talk with Talis about the new Record Use PolicyDetails: Your Records]* |-| 2008-11-28 || Kline, Heather || [http://heatherjkline.wordpress.com/2008/11/28/maelstrom-over-metadata/ "Maelstrom over Metadata"]|-| 2008-11-28 || Coyle, Karen Calhoun || [http://kcoyle.blogspot.com/2008/11/oclc-use-policy-details-use-and.html OCLC Use Policy Details: Use and Transparency]|-| 2008-12-01 || Schwartz, Christine || [http://www.catalogingfutures.com/catalogingfutures/2008/12/oclc-policy-spreading-the-bibliographic-wealth-around.html OCLC policy: spreading the bibliographic wealth around?] |-| 2008-12-01 || Sanchez, Elaine (via Autocatautocat) - || [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3c2FA61018D659CF4B95A0F938AE66965A037EAA5A3cA5EA7312DD1822479490004ED396177E96E8D2D455%40OAEXCH4SERVER40BOBCATMAIL4.oamatrix.oclctxstate.orgedu%3e Petition for OCLC Record Use to Collaboratively Re-write Policyfor Use and Transfer of WorldCat Records] (NC)* Karen Calhoun |-| 2008-12- 01 || York University Libraries Bibliographic Services || [http://www.yorku.ca/yul/bibserv/blog/?p=190 The Bib Blog: Petition for OCLC to Collaboratively Re-write Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat Records]|-| 2008-12-04 || Voss, Jacob || [http://jakoblog.de/2008/12/04/bibliographische-daten-muessen-frei-sein/ Bibliographische Daten müssen frei sein] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//jakoblog.de/2008/12/04/bibliographische-daten-muessen-frei-sein/&hl=en&langpair=auto%2Fen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 rough English translation] via Google)|-| 2008-12-07 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2008/12/elusive-moose-and-oclc.php The Elusive Moose and OCLC]|-| 2008-12-07 || barbarakitten_t (Livejournal) || [http://community.livejournal.com/library_mofo/988321.html OCLC Policy Suckage] (NC)|-| 2008-12-07 || Anonymous blogger (paraprofessional?*) || [http://kittent.wordpress.com/2008/12/07/oclc-policy-sucks/ OCLC policy Sucks]|-| 2008-12-08 || techdirt || [http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20081208/1224123056.shtml Landgrab For Ownership Of Library Catalog Data]|-| 2008-12-09 || Missouri Libr Net Corp || [http://pipeup.wordpress.com/2008/12/09/worldcat-records-policy-update/ WorldCat Records Policy Update]|-| 2008-12-09 || PALINET Cataloging Blog || [http://blog.palinet.org/metaloguecat/archives?p=118 OCLC Record Use Policy]|-| 2008-12-09 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2008/1112/notesnew-onoclc-oclcspolicy-updatedand-recordfederal-libraries.php The New OCLC Policy and Federal Libraries]|-| 2008-12-10 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2008/12/10/oclc-license-policy-a-recommendation.html Notes on OCLCLicense Policy - A Recommendation]|-| 2008-12-10 || 's Updated Record Use 'Autocat'' list discussion || [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cDE579CE2077A804AB69F6A84F17421DA0F0F37%40TFTMEXCH1.tufts.ad.tufts.edu%3e Re: The new OCLC Policyand Federal libraries] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3c17C8A0DAFF17854790F2BC013D9F5BC5132D328583%40XVS2%2dCLUSTER.yu.yale.edu%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cDE579CE2077A804AB69F6A84F17421DA0F0F38%40TFTMEXCH1.tufts.ad.tufts.edu%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cDE579CE2077A804AB69F6A84F17421DA0F0F39%40TFTMEXCH1.tufts.ad.tufts.edu%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3c63d3c8ce0812101051rf0b0cdbg825c7e26ee7c4002%40mail.gmail.com%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cPine.SOL.4.21.0812101417360.13972%2d100000%40sun8.loc.gov%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cDE579CE2077A804AB69F6A84F17421DA0F0F3A%40TFTMEXCH1.tufts.ad.tufts.edu%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cPine.SOL.4.21.0812102245300.27468%2d100000%40sun8.loc.gov%3e more] (NC)* Karen Coombs |- | 2008-12-12 || Anonymous blogger (Cainmark) || [http://cainmark.livejournal.com/629741.html OCLC trying to use its EULA to hold freely given catolog data hostage.] (NC)|-| 2008-12-12 || ''American Libraries Online'' || [http://www.librarywebchicala.org/ala/alonline/currentnews/newsarchive/2008/december2008/worldcatobjections.cfm WorldCat Policy Revision Draws Librarians’ Ire] (NC)|-| 2008-12-12 || Open Libraries Tech list || [http://mail.archive.org/pipermail/ol-tech/2008-December/thread.html#192 the land-grabs] (NC)|-| 2008-12-12 || Klienman, Molly || [http://librarycopyright.net/wordpress/?p=180 OCLC licensing saga]|-| 2008-12-13 || Schneider, Karen || [http:/11/05freerangelibrarian.com/whos2008/12/13/oclcs-recordpolicy-istrain-itstop-anywaycried-the-constable-on-the-rails/ Who’s OCLC’s policy: Train, stop, cried the constable on the rails]|-| 2008-12-15 || Wallis, Richard || [http://blogs.talis.com/panlibus/archives/2008/12/oclc-record is it anyway-sharing-yogurt-and-copyright.php OCLC Record Sharing, Yogurt, and Copyright]|-| 2008-12-16 || ''Library Journal'' || [http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA6622391.html?rssid=191 ARL/ASERL Task Force to Investigate OCLC Policy Change](NC)* Larry Alford|-| 2008-12-16 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2008/12/new-oclc-logos.php New OCLC logos], [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2008/12/666.php more]|-| 2008-12-18 || Salo, Dorothea || [http://cavlec.yarinareth.net/2008/12/18/thursday-wtfery/ Thursday WTFery]|-| 2008-12-20 || Singer Gordon, Rachel || [http://www.lisjobs.com/blog/?p=401 Mine! Mine! Mine!]|-| 2009-01-04 || McGrath, Kelley || [http://news.gmane.org/worldcatfind-root.php?message_id=%3c20439895A37DB5408D0D28C0177E097F3D90DD7C61%40EMAILBACKEND01.bsu.edu%3e OCLC's new WorldCat Record Policy, original cataloging, and 040 $a] [http:/catalog/policynews.gmane.org/trusteesletterfind-root.pdf An open letter to the php?message_id=%3c2FA61018D659CF4B95A0F938AE66965A03D09B9A%40OAEXCH4SERVER.oa.oclc.org%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cA070928F0B0F46EFA59DE0EBFFBD7D31%40cstserver.local%3e more] (NC)|-| 2009-01-07 || Houghton-Jan, Sarah || [http://librarianinblack.typepad.com/librarianinblack/2009/01/problems-with-oclc-policy-on-worldcat-records.html Problems with OCLC membership Policy on WorldCat Records] (NC)|-| 2009-01-07 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2009/01/07/bibliosnet-and-the -future-of-cataloging/ biblios.net and the future of cataloging]|-| 2009-01-09 || Leggott, Mark || [http://loomware.typepad.com/loomware/2009/01/oclc-worldcat-record-policy-petition.html OCLC WorldCat Record Use PolicyPetition](NC)* Libology |-| 2009-01-10 || Morgan, Eric Lease || [http://litablog.org/2009/01/10/eric-lease-morgans-top-tech-trends-for-ala-mid-winter-2009/ Eric Lease Morgan’s Top Tech Trends for ALA Mid-Winter, 2009]|-| 2009-01-11 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/01/this-is-like-heinlein-novel.php This is like a Heinlein novel!]|-| 2009-01-11 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/01/why-libraries-must-reject-oclc-policy.php Why libraries must reject the OCLC Policy (part 1)]|-| 2009-01-12 || Kleinman, Molly || [http://librarycopyright.net/wordpress/?p=180 OCLC licensing saga]|-| 2009-01-12 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/20082009/01/11/14/morewhy-libraries-must-reject-the-oclc-commentspolicy.html More Why Libraries Must Reject the OCLC CommentsPolicy]* LISnews |- | 2009-01-12 || Kellat, Stephen Michael || [http://www.lisnews.org/oclc_claims_ownership_data_opacs listen_lisnews_org_podcast_episode_56 LISTen: The LISNews.org Podcast -- Episode #56 (Commentary portion of episode)]|-| 2009-01-13 || Datema, Jay || [http://www.bookism.org/open/2009/01/13/lock-in-leads-to-lockdown/ Lock-in leads to lockdown]|-| 2009-01-13 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/01/oclc-protest-teeshirts-are-here.php OCLC Claims Ownership protest teeshirts are here!]|-| 2009-01-13 || OCLC, Board of Trustees, Members Council || [http://www.oclc.org/us/en/news/releases/20092.htm Review Board of Shared Data In OPACsCreation and Stewardship]|-|} * "working as staff at University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign" == Commentary Following the Announcement of the Review Board == {| class="wikitable sortable"|- style="text-align: left;"! Date !! Author !! Title|-| 2009-01-13 || Reese, Terry || [http://oregonstate.edu/~reeset/blog/archives/612 OCLC to convene a Review Board of Shared Data Creation and Stewardship]|- | 2009-01-13 || ''LISNews'' || [http://lisnews.org/oclc_convene_review_board_shared_data OCLC to convene Review Board of Shared Data]|-| 2009-01-13 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2009/01/13/oclc-creates-review-board-of-shared-data-creation-and-stewardship.html OCLC Creates Review Board of Shared Data Creation and Stewardship]|-| 2009-01-14 || Bigwood, David || [http://catalogablog.blogspot.com/2009/01/oclc-record-sharing-news.html OCLC Record Sharing News]|-| 2009-01-14 || Open Content Alliance - blog || [http://www.opencontentalliance.org/?p=162 New 2009/01/14/is-oclc-reconsidering-its-proposed-records-policy/ Is OCLC Reconsidering its Proposed Records Policy Generates Debate?]* Panlibus |- | 2009-01-14 || Styles, Rob || [http://blogs.talis.com/panlibus/archives/20082009/1101/what-are-oclc-playingis-atlistening.php What are OCLC playing at?is listening.]* Repohate |- | 2009-01-14 || Coyle, Karen || [http://repohatekcoyle.blogspot.com/20082009/1101/declarationoclc-ofpushes-independanceback-ofpolicy-metadatato-fall-2009.html Declaration OCLC pushes back policy to fall, 2009]|-| 2009-01-14 || Mark Ockerbloom, John || [http://everybodyslibraries.com/2009/01/14/chances-to-stop-and-think-about-the-future-of Independance -library-catalogs/ Chances to stop and think about the future of Metadatalibrary catalogs]* Richard Wallis |-| 2009-01-15 || Uncontrolled Vocabulary #67 (Panlibuspodcast) || [http://uncontrolledvocabulary.com/2009/01/15/uncontrolled- vocabulary-67-policy-driven-drm/ Uncontrolled Vocabulary #67 ("Policy-driven DRM")]|-| 2009-01-15 || ''AUTOCAT mailing list'' || [http://blogsnews.talisgmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cLISTSERV%25200901151548150370.1BA6%40LISTSERV.SYR.EDU%3e OCLC to review record use policy] (NC)|-| 2009-01-15 || Anonymous blogger || [http://catalogsofbabes.wordpress.com/panlibus2009/01/15/more-about-oclc-and-nipples/ From the Catalogs of Babes: more about OCLC and nipples]|-| 2009-01-15 || Chatterjee, Anirvan || [http://journal.bookfinder.com/archives/2008entry/11000424.html Bookfinder Journal: Notes from all over] (NC)|-| 2009-01-15 || Schwartz, Christine || [http:/keeping/www.catalogingfutures.com/catalogingfutures/2009/01/oclc-establishes-review-board-to-look-at-question-of-shared-library-data.html OCLC establishes review board to look at question of shared library data]|-| 2009-01-16 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/01/library-social-media-wins-one.php Library social media wins one]|-| 2009-01-16 || ''American Libraries Online'' || [http://www.ala.org/ala/alonline/currentnews/newsarchive/2009/January2009/worldcatreview.cfm OCLC Delays WorldCat Policy Pending Review Board] (NC)|-| 2009-01-17 || Matienzo, Mark A. || [http://thesecretmirror.com/mark/this-is-all-im-going-to-say-on-this-here-blogsite-concerning-the-brouhaha-about-the-policy-for-use-and-transfer-of-worldcat-records-because-i-have-other-more-interesting-and-more-complex-problems-t/comment-page-1 This Is All I’m Going To Say On This Here Blogsite ...]|-| 2009-01-22 || Grossman, Wendy M; ''The Guardian'' || [http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2009/jan/22/library-search-engines-books Why you can't find a library book inyour search engine] (NC)|-the| 2009-bag01-22 || ''FriendFeed commentary on Guardian article || [http://friendfeed.com/e/ae0253d3-1af3-404f-8889-e74a472b1d11/Why-you-can-t-find-a-library-book-in-your-search/ FriendFeed] (NC)|-| 2009-01-21 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/01/guardian-asks-why-you-cant-find-library.php Keeping The Guardian asks "Why you can't find a library book in your search engine?"]|-| 2009-01-22 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/2009/01/22/oclc-in-the WorldCat -guardian/ OCLC in the bagGuardian]* Richard Wallis |-| 2009-01-22 || Bermès, Manue || [http://figoblog.org/node/1953 Le côté obscur de la force ?] (Panlibus[http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//figoblog.org/node/1953&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translation to English] from French courtesy of Google) [NC]|- | 2009-01-22 || Lone Wolf Librarian || [http://lonewolflibrarian.wordpress.com/2009/01/22/oclc-policy-changes-appear-in-international-media012209/ OCLC Policy Change Controversy Appears in International Media]|-| 2009-01-22 || Biancu, Bonaria || [http://bonariabiancu.wordpress.com/2009/01/22/libraries-need-freedom/ Libraries need freedom] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//bonariabiancu.wordpress.com/2009/01/22/libraries-need-freedom/&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translation to English] from Italian courtesy of Google)|-| 2009-01-22 || Powell, Andy || [http://efoundations.typepad.com/efoundations/2009/01/why-cant-i-find-a-library-book-in-my-search-engine.html Why can't I find a library book in my search engine?] (NC)|-| 2009-01-22 || West, Jessamyn || [http://www.librarian.net/stax/2661/why-you-cant-google-a-library-book/ why you can’t google a library book]|-| 2009-01-22 || Baumgart, Jessica || [http://blogs.talislaw.harvard.edu/jkbaumga/2009/01/22/why-you-can%e2%80%99t-google-a-library-book/ why you can’t google a library book]|-| 2009-01-22 || Ottevanger, Jeremy || [http://doofercall.blogspot.com/panlibus2009/archives01/2008worldcatoclc-get-rough-end-of-guardians.html WorldCat/11OCLC get the rough end of the Guardian's stick]|-| 2009-01-23 || Marcel || [http://mondayevening.wordpress.com/2009/01/23/finding-and-reading-books/ Finding and reading books]|-| 2009-01-23 || ''the.effing.librarian'' || [http://effinglibrarian.blogspot.com/2009/01/oclc-anyvs-questionseveryone.php html OCLC – any questionsvs. Everyone]|-| 2009-01-23 || Miedema, John || [http://johnmiedema.ca/2009/01/23/youve-heard-of-worldcat-now-meet-fuzzycat/ You’ve Heard of WorldCat, Now Meet FuzzyCat]|-| 2009-01-23 || Cairns, Michael || [http://personanondata.blogspot.com/2009/01/bibliographic-studies.html Bibliographic Studies]|-| 2009-01-25 || ''AUTOCAT mailing list'' || [http://article.gmane.org/gmane.education.libraries.autocat/19178 OCLC and the Guardian] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cPine.SOL.4.21.0901250927110.9718%2d100000%40sun8.loc.gov%3e more][http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cPine.SOL.4.21.0901252149140.28128%2d100000%40sun8.loc.gov%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3c497F24E6020000CA0004B82A%40ntgwgate.loc.gov%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cPine.SOL.4.21.0901271743270.24031%2d100000%40sun8.loc.gov%3e more] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cPine.SOL.4.21.0901271835590.24031%2d100000%40sun8.loc.gov%3e more] (NC)* Rob Styles |- | 2009-01-26 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://dynamicorangebibwild.wordpress.com/20082009/1101/0626/oclcenforcing-recordcataloging-usagecopyright-whose-interest/ enforcing catalog record copyrightis in whose interest?]|-contracts| 2009-01-26 || Ahlberg, Carina || [http://www.biblioteksrelaterat.se/2009/01/varf%C3%B6r-man-inte-hittar-bibliotekets-b%C3%B6cker-i-google.html Varför man inte hittar bibliotekets böcker i Google] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//www.biblioteksrelaterat.se/2009/01/varf%25C3%25B6r-man-inte-hittar-bibliotekets-b%25C3%25B6cker-i-google.html&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translation to English] from Sweedish courtesy of Google)|-| 2009-01-27 || Calhoun, Karen || [http://www.slideshare.net/amarintha/creating-and-sustaining-communities-around-shared-data-the-law/ case-of-oclc-presentation Creating and Sustaining Communities Around Shared Data: The Case of OCLC] (NC)|-| 2009-01-27 || Calhoun, Record UsageKaren || [http://community.oclc.org/metalogue/archives/2009/01/data-sharing-libraries-and-the.html Data Sharing, CopyrightLibraries, Contracts and the LawLandscape of the Web](NC)* Rob Styles |- | 2009-01-27 || Oder, Norman, ''Library Journal'' || [http://dynamicorangewww.libraryjournal.com/2008article/11CA6632413.html OCLC Defends Records Policy, Faces Questions, Suggestions, and Criticisms] (NC)|-| 2009-01-27 || Murray, Peter || [http:/14/moredltj.org/article/oclc-records-use-policy-1/ Consideration of OCLC Records Use Policy]|-| 2009-01-27 || ''York University Libraries Bibliographic Services'' || [http://www.yorku.ca/yul/bibserv/blog/?p=195 Guardian Article on OCLC, Libraries and the Internet]|-| 2009-01-28 || Lone Wolf Librarian || [http://lonewolflibrarian.wordpress.com/2009/01/28/oclc-yet-againtries-to-defend-controversial-policy-shift012809/ More OCLC Policy…Yet Again Unsuccessfully Tries to Defend Controversial Major Policy Shift…01.28.09]* Rob Styles |- | 2009-01-28 || ''LISNews'' || [http://dynamicorangewww.lisnews.org/oclc_defends_records_policy_faces_questions_suggestions_and_criticisms OCLC Defends Records Policy, Faces Questions, Suggestions, and Criticisms]|-| 2009-01-28 || Kellat, Stephen Michael || [http://lisnews.org/reflections_upon_lj_story Reflections upon an LJ story]|-| 2009-01-28 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://bibwild.wordpress.com/20082009/1101/1828/schroedingers_worldcatyet-more-on-copyright-and-cataloging/ Schroedinger’s yet more on copyright and cataloging]|-| 2009-01-28 || Ockerbloom, John Mark || [http://everybodyslibraries.com/2009/01/28/open-catalog-apis-and-data-ala-presentation-notes-posted/ Open catalog APIs and data: ALA presentation notes posted]|-| 2009-01-28 || Corrado, Ed || [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2009/01/28/library-journal-report-on-the-oclc-worldcat-policy/ Library Journal report on the OCLC WorldCatpolicy discussion]* Roy Litwin |- | 2009-01-28 || Murray, Peter || [http://libraryjuicepressdltj.org/article/oclc-records-use-policy-2/ Further Consideration of OCLC Records Use Policy]|-| 2009-01-28 || ''liblicense-l mailing list'' || [http://www.library.yale.edu/~llicense/ListArchives/0901/msg00115.html OCLC's New License for Bibliographic Records] (NC)|-| 2009-01-29 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2009/01/29/oclc-license-policy-at-ala-midwinter.html OCLC License Policy at ALA Midwinter]|-| 2009-01-30 || ''AUTOCAT mailing list'' || [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?pmessage_id=792 OCLC Powergrab%3c705314404.777621233352002233.JavaMail.root%40sz0136a.westchester.pa.mail.comcast.net%3e Copyright in Bib Records] [http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cPine.SOL.4.21.0901311900170.1301%2d100000%40sun8.loc.gov%3e more][http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?message_id=%3cPine.SOL.4.21.0902010026210.29243%2d100000%40sun8.loc.gov%3e more] (NC)* Sarah Hartman|-Caverly | 2009- 02-01 || Spalding, Tim || [http://seriallyyourswww.librarything.com/thingology/2009/02/evil-326.php The evil 3.26%]|-| 2009-02-02 || Mijnsbergen, Edwin || [http://www.zbdigitaal.nl/2009/02/te-lui-om-te-begrijpen.html Te lui om te begrijpen] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//www.zbdigitaal.nl/2009/02/te-lui-om-te-begrijpen.html&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translation to English] courtesy of Google)|-| 2009-02-02 || Lone Wolf Librarian || [http://lonewolflibrarian.wordpress.com/20082009/1102/1302/finallibrarything-policyresponds-to-oclcs-monopoly-counter-defense020209/ LibraryThing Responds to OCLC’s Questioning of Motives…02.02.09]|- | 2009-02-02 || McNamara, Frances || [http://bdfar.wordpress.com/2009/02/02/oclc-hullaballou-ala-midwinter-2009-monday/ OCLC Hullaballou ALA Midwinter 2009 Monday]|-| 2009-02-06 || OCLC || [http://www.oclc.org/us/en/news/releases/200910.htm OCLC Board of Trustees, Members Council name Review Board of Shared Data Creation and Stewardship.]|-| 2009-02-07 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2009/02/07/oclc-announces-review-board-members.html OCLC Announces Review Board Members]|-| 2009-02-07 || Murray, Peter || [http://dltj.org/article/oclc-review-board-members/ Members of the OCLC Review Board Announced]|-| 2009-02-09 || ''OCLC Review Board'' || [http://community.oclc.org/reviewboard/archives/2009/02/from-the-review-board.html From the Review Board] (Public comment space)|-| 2009-02-10 || Ostrowsky, Ben || [http://blog.benostrowsky.com/2009/02/10/oclc-should-share-worldcat-data-for-commercial-and-noncommercial-use/ OCLC should share WorldCat data for commercial and noncommercial use]|-| 2009-02-10 || McNamara, Frances || [http://bdfar.wordpress.com/2009/02/10/oclc-review-board/ OCLC Review Board]|-| 2009-02-10 || Murray, Peter || [http://dltj.org/article/oclc-review-board-blog/ OCLC Review Board’s Blog]|-| 2009-02-18 || Lawson, Steve || [http://stevelawson.name/seealso/archives/2009/02/matters_of_policy.html Matters of Policy]|-| 2009-02-19 || ''Miss Information'' || [http://closedstacks.wordpress.com/2009/02/19/big-brother-is-facebook/ Big Brother is Facebook (?)]|-| 2009-02-19 || Ivy || [http://catalogsofbabes.wordpress.com/2009/02/19/facebook-or-oclc-perhaps-both/ Facebook or OCLC? Perhaps both.]|-| 2009-02-20 || ARL || [http://www.arl.org/bm~doc/oclc-report-jan09.pdf Ad Hoc Task Force to Review the Proposed OCLC Policy for Use andTransfer of WorldCat Records: Final Report to the ARL Board, January 30, 2009] (PDF)|-| 2009-02-20 || ResourceShelf || [http://www.resourceshelf.com/2009/02/20/arl-recommends-community-wide-process-to-develop-new-oclc-policy-for-use-transfer-of-worldcat-records/ ARL Recommends Community-postWide Process to Develop New OCLC Policy for Use & Transfer of WorldCat Records]|-by| 2009-02-20 || Jastram, Iris || [http://pegasuslibrarian.blogspot.com/2009/02/oclc-question-for-masses.html OCLC Question for the masses]|-| 2009-02-20 || Walk, Paul || [http:/ /blog.paulwalk.net/2009/02/20/smoke-and-mirrors-or-good-intentions/ Smoke and mirrors, or good intentions?]|-| 2009-02-21 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2009/02/21/oclc-policy-final-report-to-the-arl-board.html OCLC Policy - Final ‘Policy Report to the ARL Board]|-| 2009-02-21 || Brantley, Peter || [http://blogs.lib.berkeley.edu/shimenawa.php/2009/02/21/sending-oclc-on-its-way Sending OCLC on its way]|-| 2009-02-23 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/02/research-libraries-clobber-oclc-policy.php Research libraries clobber OCLC Policy ]|-| 2009-02-23 || Goldstein, Jeremy || [http://geekylibrarian.wordpress.com/2009/02/23/another-blow/ Another Blow]|-| 2009-02-23 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2009/02/23/librarything-on-the-arl-report.html LibraryThing on the ARL Report]|-| 2009-02-23 || ''Library Journal'' || [http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA6639210.html ARL Says OCLC Should Revise WorldCat Policy] (NC)|-| 2009-02-23 || Lawson, Steve || [http://stevelawson.name/seealso/archives/2009/02/arl_task_force_report_on_the_oclc_records_policy.html ARL Task Force report on the OCLC records policy]|- | 2009-02-24 || Vielmetti, Edward || [http://vielmetti.typepad.com/superpatron/2009/02/pitchforks-for Use and Transfer -oclc-rebellion-against-mandatory-licensing-for-cooperatively-developed-catalog-data.html Pitchforks for OCLC: rebellion against mandatory licensing for cooperatively developed catalog data] (NC)|-| 2009-03-09 || Pohl, Adrian || [http://www.uebertext.org/2009/03/ein-artikel-uber-die-oclc-metadaten.html Ein Artikel zu OCLCs Metadaten-Policy] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//www.uebertext.org/2009/03/ein-artikel-uber-die-oclc-metadaten.html&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translation to English] courtesy of WorldCat Records’ Posted by Google)|-|2009-03-09 || Pohl, Adrian || OCLC, WorldCat und die Metadatenkontroverse. In: Bibliotheksdienst 43 (2009), pp. 274-290. [http://www.zlb.de/aktivitaeten/bd_neu/heftinhalte2009/Erschliessung020309BD.pdf Electronic Version](PDF).* Slashdot |- | 2009-03-22 || Voß, Jacob || [http://newsjakoblog.slashdotde/2009/03/22/zwei-artikel-zu-hochschulbibliografien-und-zur-worldcat-policy-im-bibliotheksdienst/ Zwei Artikel zu Hochschulbibliografien und zur WorldCat Policy im Bibliotheksdienst] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//jakoblog.de/2009/03/22/zwei-artikel-zu-hochschulbibliografien-und-zur-worldcat-policy-im-bibliotheksdienst/&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translation to English] courtesy of Google)|-| 2009-03-27 || Murray, Peter || [http://dltj.org/article/oclc-review-board-survey/ Survey Responses Sought from the OCLC Review Board on Shared Data Creation and Stewardship]|-| 2009-03-30 || Cataloging Policy Committee of the OnLine Audiovisual Catalogers, Inc.pl|| [http://www.olacinc.org/drupal/?sidq=node/350 OCLC’s Proposed Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat® Records] (NC)|-| 2009-04-02 || Smithsonian Institution Libraries || [http://smithsonianlibraries.si.edu/smithsonianlibraries/2009/04/oclcs-policy-for-use-and-transfer-of-worldcat-records.html OCLC's Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat Records] (NC)|-| 2009-04-08|| Rochkind, Jonathan || [http:/11/13bibwild.wordpress.com/1929213 Non2009/04/07/oclc-Profit Org Claims Rights In record-use-survey-comments/ OCLC record use survey comments]|-|2009-04-23 || Frumkin, Jeremy || [http://digitallibrarian.org/?p=59 Open Library Catalog Dataand OCLC]|- |2009-04-24 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/04/oclc-end-game.php The OCLC End Game]|-|2009-04-27 || Coombs, Karen || [http://www.librarywebchic.net/wordpress/2009/04/27/on-recent-oclc-announcements/ On recent OCLC announcements]|-| 2009-05-11 || International Coalition of Library Consortia (ICOLC) || [http://www.library.yale.edu/consortia/statement-oclcrecorduse.htm Statement on the Proposed OCLC Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat Records] (NC)* Stefano Mazzocchi |- | 2009-05-12 || Murray, Peter || [http://www.betaversiondltj.org/~stefanoarticle/linotypeoclc-record-use-policy-update/newsOCLC Record Use Policy Issue Coming to a Head]|-| 2009-05-12 || Corrado, Ed || [http:/220/ Rule #1 blog.ecorrado.us/2009/05/12/icolc-statement-on-the-proposed-oclc-policy-for Surviving Paradigm Shifts-use-and-transfer-of-worldcat-records/ ICOLC “Statement on the Proposed OCLC Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat Records.”]|-| 2009-05-13 || Spalding, Tim || [http: Don’t S**t Where You Eat//www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/05/oclc-policy-good-night.php OCLC Policy, Good night]* Suburban Banshee |- | 2009-05-13 || Rochkind, Jonathan || [http://suburbanbansheebibwild.wordpress.com/20082009/1105/1413/well-said-icolc/ Well said, ICOLC]|-| 2009-05-13 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2009/05/13/icolc-weighs-in-on-oclc.html ICOLC weighs in on OCLC]|-gets| 2009-grabby05-14 || Dibbell, Jeremy || [http:/ /philobiblos.blogspot.com/2009/05/death-blow-to-oclcs-proposed-policy.html Death Blow to OCLC Gets Grabby's Proposed Policy?]* Terry Reese |- | 2009-05-15 || Mark Ockerbloom, John || [http://oregonstateeverybodyslibraries.educom/2009/05/15/will-oclc-move-to-a-service-oriented-business-model-for-bibliographic-data/ Will OCLC move to a service-oriented business model for bibliographic data?]|-| 2009-05-15 || Corrado, Ed || [http:/~reeset/blog.ecorrado.us/archives2009/574 OCLC’s 05/15/eluna-uugi-and-codi-endorse-icolc-statement-on-the-proposed new guidelines -oclc-policy-for the -use-and-transfer -of bibliographic -worldcat-records/ ELUNA, UUGI, and CODI endorse ICOLC Statement on the Proposed OCLC Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat Records]* Terry Reese |- | 2009-05-15 || Baker, Gavin (Open Access News) || [http://oregonstatewww.earlham.edu/~reesetpeters/fos/2009/05/icolc-opposes-oclc-data-policy.html ICOLC opposes OCLC data policy] (NC)|} == Commentary Following the Members Council May 2009 Review Board Presentation == On [[18 May]] [[2009]], Jennifer Younger (Chair of the [http://www.oclc.org/us/en/worldcat/catalog/policy/board/default.htm Review Board of Shared Data Creation and Stewardship]) presented preliminary findings to the OCLC Members Council. Two days later, a [http://vidego.multicastmedia.com/player.php?p=v07n97t9 recording] of Dr. Younger's presentation and the [http://www.oclc.org/us/en/worldcat/catalog/policy/20090518-MC-Jennifer_Younger.pdf presentation slides] were posted on the OCLC website. {| class="wikitable sortable"|- style="text-align: left;"! Date !! Author !! Title|-| 2009-05-20 || Corrado, Ed || [http://blog.ecorrado.us/2009/05/20/oclc-review-board-of-shared-data-creation-stewardship-recommends-to-formally-withdraw-the-proposed-worldcat-policy/ OCLC Review Board of Shared Data Creation & Stewardship recommends to “Formally withdraw the proposed (WorldCat) policy”]|-| 2009-05-20 || Wallis, Richard || [http://blogs.talis.com/panlibus/archives/579 What would it look like if 2009/05/oclc-dumps-new-record-reuse-policy.php OCLC was broken upDumps New Record Reuse Policy]|-| 2009-05-20 || Murray, Peter || [http://dltj.org/article/oclc-review-board-initial-recommendations/ OCLC Review Board Recommends the Withdraw of Proposed Policy; Advocates for an Open Process]|-| 2009-05-20 || Spalding, Tim || [http://www.librarything.com/thingology/2009/05/non-est-potestas-oclc-policy-withdrawn_21.php/ Non est potestas: OCLC Policy withdrawn]|-| 2009-05-22 || Mijnsbergen, Edwin || [http://www.zbdigitaal.nl/2009/05/het-beleid-van-oclc-nieuwe.html Het beleid van OCLC: nieuwe ontwikkelingen] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//www.zbdigitaal.nl/2009/05/het-beleid-van-oclc-nieuwe.html&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translation to English from Dutch]courtesy of Google)* Terry Reese |- | 2009-05-22 || Leggott, Mark || [http://oregonstateloomware.edutypepad.com/~reesetloomware/blog2009/archives05/582 A look at non-est-potestas-oclc-policy-withdrawn.html Non est potestas: OCLC Policy Withdrawn] (NC)|-| 2009-05-26 || National Diet Library (Japan) || [http://current.ndl.go.jp/node/12962 WorldCatレコード利用・再配布の新ポリシーに対する審査委員会の審査結果] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//current.ndl.go.jp/node/12962&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translation to English from Japanese] courtesy of Google) (NC)|-| 2009-05-28 || Coyle, Karen || [http://kcoyle.blogspot.com/2009/06/oclc-policy.html OCLC Policy - What is the Question?]|} == Commentary Following the Release of the Review Board Final Report == On [[26 Jun]] [[2009]], OCLC published the [http://www.oclc.org/worldcat/catalog/FinalReport_ReviewBoard.pdf final report] of the [http://www.oclc.org/worldcat/catalog/policy/board/default.htm Review Board of Shared Data Creation and Stewardship] and announced the formal withdrawal of the proposed Policy for Use and Transfer of WorldCat WorldCat® Records revision. {| class="wikitable sortable"|- style="text-align: left;"! Date !! Author !! Title|-| 2009-06-28 || Eustis, Jennifer || [http://celeripedean.wordpress.com/2009/06/28/final-report-from-the-review-board-on-shared-data-creation-and-stewardship/ Final Report from the Review Board on Shared Data Creation and Stewardship]* Uncontrolled Vocabulary #62 |-| 2009-06-28 || Murray, Peter || [http://dltj.org/article/record-use-policy-withdrawn/ OCLC Formally Withdraws Proposed Record Use Policy]|-| 2009-06-28 || Pohl, Adrian || [http://www.uebertext.org/2009/06/oclc-policy-zuruckgezogen.html OCLC - Policy zurückgezogen] (podcast[http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//www.uebertext.org/2009/06/oclc-policy-zuruckgezogen.html Translated to English from German] courtesy of Google) |- | 2009-06-29 || Mason, Rick || [http://uncontrolledvocabularywww.libology.com/2008blog/112009/1206/uncontrolled29/oclc-vocabularywithdraws-62records-polic.html OCLC Withdraws Records Policy]|-| 2009-06-29 || National Diet Library (Japan) || [http://current.ndl.go.jp/node/13447 OCLC、WorldCatレコード利用・再配布に係る新ポリシーを公式に撤回] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//current.ndl.go.jp/node/13447&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translated to English from Japanese] courtesy of Google) (NC)|-| 2009-06-29 || Bourg, Chris || [http://chrisbourg.wordpress.com/2009/06/29/oclc-withdraws-proposed-policy-on-use-of-wc-records/ OCLC withdraws proposed policy on use of WC records]|-| 2009-07-01 || Baker, Gavin (Open Access News) || [http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/2009/07/oclc-scraps-worldcat-data-policy-will.html OCLC scraps WorldCat data policy, will write new one] (NC)|-| 2009-07-07 || Ray, MJ || [http://www.news.software.coop/oclc-record-use-reboot/699/ OCLC Record Use: Reboot]|-| 2009-07-14 || Anglada, Lluís || [http://bdig.blogspot.com/2009/07/sobre-oclc-proposito-del-ala-de-chicago.html Sobre OCLC apropósito del ALA de Chicago] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A//bdig.blogspot.com/2009/07/sobre-reliableoclc-guideproposito-del-ala-de-chicago.html&hl=en&langpair=auto%7cen&tbb=1&ie=UTF-8 Translated toEnglish from Spanish] courtesy of Google)|-unicorns| 2009-07-29 || Wallis, Richard || [http:/ A Reliable Guide /blogs.talis.com/panlibus/archives/2009/07/jisc-grasp-the-marc-record-re-use-legality-nettle.php JISC Grasp the Marc Record Re-use Legality Nettle]|-| 2009-09-14 || OCLC || [http://www.oclc.org/us/en/news/releases/200948.htm OCLC Board of Trustees convenes Council to Unicornsstudy and develop new WorldCat Record Use Policy](NC)|-| 2009-09-15 || Hadro, Josh ''Library Journal'' || [http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA6697129.html OCLC Appoints Council to Revamp WorldCat Record Use Policy] (NC)|-| 2009-09-18 || Eustis, Jennifer || [http://celeripedean.wordpress.com/2009/09/18/oclc-back-to-the-review-policy/ OCLC: Back to the Review Policy]|-| 2009-11-08 || Library 2.0 Gang || [http://www.alatechsource.org/blog/2009/11/library-20-gang-1109-the-cataloguing-services-landscape.html The Cataloguing Services Landscape] (NC)|} == Comments on WorldCat Rights and Responsibilities for the OCLC Cooperative == Commentary after the release of the [http://www.oclc.org/worldcat/catalog/policy/default.htm WorldCat Rights and Responsibilities for the OCLC Cooperative] draft on 7-Apr-2010. {| class="wikitable sortable"|- style="text-align: left;"! Date !! Author !! Title|-| 2010-04-07 || Mason, Rick || [http://www.libology.com/blog/2010/04/07/oclc-and-data.html OCLC and Data]|-| 2010-04-07 || Coyle, Karen || [http://kcoyle.blogspot.com/2010/04/oclc-record-use-policy.html OCLC record use policy]|-| 2010-04-07 || Hadro, Josh -- ''Library Journal'' || [http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA6725522.html Library Journal article] (NC)|-| 2010-04-07 || Morrison, Heather || [http://poeticeconomics.blogspot.com/2010/04/worldcat-rights-and-responsibilites-for.html WorldCat rights and responsibilites ... comments] (NC)|-| 2010-04-07 || Various || [http://blogs.talis.com/panlibus/archives/2010/04/oclc-talk-with-talis-about-draft-worldcat-rights-responsibilities.php Talking with Talis: OCLC Talk with Talis about Draft WorldCat Rights & Responsibilities]|-| 2010-04-14 || University of Melbourne Library staff blog || [http://blogs.unimelb.edu.au/libraryintelligencer/2010/04/13/worldcat-rights-and-responsibilities-for-the-oclc-cooperative%e2%80%94draft-for-community-review/ WorldCat Rights and Responsibilities for the OCLC Cooperative—Draft for Community Review]|-| 2010-04-14 || ''carolslib'' || [http://carolslib.wordpress.com/2010/04/14/oclcs-latest-policy/ OCLC’s latest policy]|-| 2010-04-15 || Hadro, Josh -- ''Library Journal'' || [http://www.libraryjournal.com/article/CA6726412.html As Record Use Policy Draws Comments, OCLC Reacts Quickly] (NC)|-| 2010-04-15 || Pohl, Adrian || [http://www.uebertext.org/2010/04/oclcs-policy-und-die-public-domain.html OCLCs Policy und die Public Domain] ([http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http://www.uebertext.org/2010/04/oclcs-policy-und-die-public-domain.html Translated to English from German] courtesy of Google) |-|}

Sometimes the best insight comes in the comments added to blog postings and other stories. [http://pipes.yahoo.com/pipes/pipe.info?_id=jOpatQmu3RGENlDTBRNMsA This Yahoo! Pipe] (also available as an [http://pipes.yahoo.com/pipes/pipe.run?_id=jOpatQmu3RGENlDTBRNMsA&_render=rss RSS feed]) is a concatenation of all of the comments from the postings and stories above listed on this page -- with the exception of those marked "(NC)" because of use of software that doesn't support comment feeds. It was last updated as of [http://wiki.code4lib.org/index.php?title=OCLC_Policy_Change&oldid=1367 5792 page revision 13675792]. [[Category: OCLC]]